About dygo

Graduate Student at the University of Texas at Austin

Responses to Halpern-Eliot-Bigler et al. study and their reply

(originally published Jan. 13, 2012)

My brother-in-law Dr. Doug Coldwell, Professor of Radiology at University of Louisville Hospital, just wrote me.

Among other things, he said, “Saw your letter to the editor in Science. Significant: how many classics professors have ever been published there?”

I didn’t even know it had appeared. The editors never contacted me. But they did do a good job of editing my letter.

If you want to see my and other responses to the Halpern-Eliot-Bigler-et al. study and their reply, go to:

Science 13 January 2012: 165-168.

Single-Sex Education: Parameters Too Narrow

Palaima, Science 13 January 2012: 166.DOI:10.1126/science.335.6065.166-b.

The reading is not encouraging of a positive view of their research and what should be their professional lack of bias in conducting research.

I say they examined only standardized test scores. They reply that they cited a study that examined other things. But they do not use those other things in their examination!

And their response still makes a huge and unwarranted a priori assumption about what causes the lower rate of ‘failed marriages’ (if it is even so, and if it is a bad thing for marriages to ‘fail’) among dual-gender-schooled people.

They are still using the study of 40-year-old British males as the evidence for single-gender failures.

In their reply, they conveniently leave out the ‘British’. My whole point was whether a study of British middle-aged males is applicable to our American experience.

They say that the Brit male study is suggestive of their views. This is a wishful assertion. They need to disprove that other factors are at work.

They assume that by going to two-gender schools, boys and girls learn how to interact and solve interpersonal problems, so that when they are adults their marriages ‘last’.

But they nowhere test the quality of those ‘lasting marriages’ or whether lasting marriages are an indication of adult human happiness or even a social good.

They do not even consider whether by attending two-gender schools men and women, when young, learn patterns of power-relationship behaviors that keep the women in their place and the men, too, in marriages that should end.

Tom

Report on Visit – Dimitri Nakassis

(Original posted in 2010. -Ed.)

My short visit to UT and PASP gave me the opportunity to present aspects of my dissertation research and new ideas stemming from it. I gave a talk to the department on Thursday November 12th about the extent to which the model of the activities of Pylian elites based on the Linear B evidence, which I developed in my dissertation, can shed light on thorny problems in the analysis of Mycenaean archaeology. On Friday, I lectured to Tom Palaima’s undergraduate class on Aegean Prehistory (AHC 378) about the composition of Mycenaean society and the extent to which older managerial models should be modified in light of the prosopographical analysis from my dissertation.

My visit also allowed me to meet with faculty and students from UT and at other institutions. I met with Tom Palaima and Cynthia Shelmerdine to discuss a variety of topics, including of course things Mycenaean. I also discussed the Archaic symposium with Adam Rabinowitz, and Cypriot archaeology with former fellow PASPian and colleague at Trinity Unviersity in San Antonio, Nicolle Hirschfeld. I had the chance to talk to several graduate students at UT Classics, including Dygo Tosa, Mary Jane Cuyler and Alissa Stoimenoff, and Jamie Aprile from UCLA, and the undergraduates from Tom’s Aegean Prehistory class.

On Friday night I attended a fascinating lecture with Tom and recent UT Classics Ph.D. John Friend on “Dionysus in 69 in ’09: Looking Back, Looking Forward” (by Richard Schechner), which taught me a lot about modern theatre and the adaptation of Greek drama.

Otherwise, the weather in Austin was fantastic, and I managed to eat Texas barbecue at two of my favorite places, Rudy’s on 183 North and The Salt Lick in Driftwood.

Report on Visit – Ruth Palmer

(Original posted in 2010. -Ed.)

Report on Nov. 30 – Dec. 3, 2009 visit by Ruth Palmer

I wish to thank Tom Palaima and the Department of Classics at the University of Texas at Austin, for bringing me to Austin, and providing the opportunity to work in PASP and present my work to such an energizing audience of undergraduates, graduate students, faculty and visiting scholars. Sharing meals with students and faculty also provided an opportunity to talk in a less formal setting than a classroom or lecture hall. Adams House, the bed and breakfast at which I stayed, was very comfortable and accommodating. I had spent nine months in 1993-94 at UT Austin as a postdoctoral fellow working on my book, Wine in the Mycenaean Palace Economy, so my return to Austin was like a homecoming.

I was invited to teach a class of Tom’s upper level history course, AHC 378, on the status and occupations of the women workers in the Mycenaean Linear B tablets, on Monday Nov. 30, and give a Classics colloquium on my current research project, “What the scribe saw: artistic representations of deer and the invention of the Mycenaean deer ideogram,” on Thurs. Dec. 3. I was aided greatly in the deer presentation through access to the resources of PASP concerning the forms of the deer ideogram.

During my visit I had the opportunity to attend lectures by other visitors, first Lisa Fentriss’ talk on Monday evening on her work at Villa Magna, where the excavators have uncovered an amazing wine producing facility which served as the focal point in the villa of Marcus Aurelius. This reminded me of some of the Minoan wine pressing facilities from LM I, which, although of much humbler dimensions, were also show pieces attesting to the owner’s agricultural wealth. I also attended Elpida Hadjidaki’s class Wednesday afternoon where she presented the results of her excavation of the Minoan shipwreck found in the gulf of Mirabello, and the problems faced by underwater excavations. And on Wednesday evening, I went to Joe Carter’s talk on the evidence for settlement in the periods leading up to and through the Roman occupation of the Chora of Metapontum.

I also took part in many enjoyable conversations over lunch and dinner, notably dinner at Mothers with Tom Palaima on Monday and on Tuesday night, with Tom and Debbie Lee, who was my student at Ohio University. At lunch Tuesday with Adam Rabinowitz, we discussed drinking and dining rituals and the symposium. At a picnic lunch with the students from the history class on Wednesday, they had great questions and comments. Over coffee that afternoon, Jenny Moody told me about her research on climate change in Crete, and the evidence for the two species of deer brought to Crete in the Bronze Age and later. This was vital information for my research, and I am grateful to her for pointing this out. At dinner Wednesday night with Cynthia Shelmerdine, we talked about the excavations at Iklaina and another of my students who had taken part this summer. On Thursday night, five of the graduate students took me out to a wonderful café, whose name I don’t recall, and talked about their coursework and fieldwork. This was a wonderful, invigorating conclusion to a great visit. Since I have relatives living in the Austin area, I hope to come back to Austin and be able to work at PASP, and continue to communicate with the students and scholars I met here. This visit was an amazing and invigorating experience for me, and I hope you enjoyed it as much as I did.

Ruth Palmer
Associate Professor
Department of Classics and World Religions

Report on Visit – Vassilis Petrakis

(Original posted in 2011. -Ed.)

Vassilis Petrakis visited PASP and UT Classics from March 26th to April 30th and worked on the Mycenaean material for his current projects on Linear B monograms, analysis of references to kingship ideology and preparation of the Linear A ‘archive’ of Kato Zakros for final publication. Dr Petrakis was also actively engaged in the Linear B seminar directed by Professor Tom Palaima.

 Vassilis reports:

My visit to the Program in Aegean Scripts and Prehistory has been a most exciting opportunity to visit what is arguably the current ‘cosmological center’ of Linear B studies.

The excellent facilities, the abundance of research resources (including the proximity of the Classics and PCL library collections) and, most importantly, Tom Palaima’s keen interest and natural hospitality made my 5-week stay a most memorable time and one of my most intense periods of research in the field of Aegean writing systems.

My project on the Linear B monograms, which is planned to result in a monograph under the working title Monogrammata Mycenaea, benefited directly from my access (a) to the archives of Emmett Bennett Jr, particularly those few unpublished notes for articles that were never fully developed, and (b) from the examination of the excellent 1:1 photographs of tablets from Pylos, Knossos and Mycenae. The latter particularly reduced my need to have autopsies of the documents down to a few problematic cases. I was also able to test a few ideas from this forthcoming word on the Linear B seminar.

During my stay here, I was able to pursue my interest in Mycenaean kingship through discussions and presentations. It is always a rare opportunity and honor to be able to discuss this specific topic in the UT Classics Department, which hosted my stay.

I participated in the Spring Colloquium of the Classics Department with a talk on ‘Changing Perspectives on Late Bronze Age Aegean kingship: Anthropology, Mycenology and Aegean Archaeology‘ (April 8th, 2011), which served as a basis for testing the impact of some new ideas and a great opportunity to get precious feedback. Extended sessions with Tom Palaima on the ‘Minoan’ components of what we have come to consider as the ‘Mycenaean’ kingship ideology were particularly stimulating for me.

Although this was not planned from the outset, I was also able to use PASP’s facilities to lay down some basic work towards the final publication of the Linear A ‘archive’ from the Minoan palace of Kato Zakros. This project, which will be ascribed within my participation in the Zakros study seasons directed by Lefteris Platon (University of Athens), will be supported by the Institute of Classical Studies (University of London) through the Michael Ventris Memorial Award for Mycenaean Studies (2011-2012).

My participation in the Linear B seminar directed by Tom Palaima lasted over 5 sessions (each for the relevant weeks of my stay here). In these, I was able to present topics on religion, economy/ trade and warfare and discuss extensively with students.

During my first session (March 28th), issues of craft-specialization, socio-economic structure and Late Bronze Age/Early Iron Age were addressed, focusing on the survival (or non-survival) of the Linear B technical and political terminology into the 1st millennium BC alphabetic testimonia.

For the next two sessions (April 4th and 11th), I made a short presentation on the evidence for theonyms in the Linear B records, discussing their use, distribution and later Greek survivals. Specific tablets were discussed in order to present a method of working with Mycenaean texts through photographic corpora, transcriptions and lexica. We also focused on the semantic nuances of some specific terms, such as po-ti-ni-ja.

The fourth session (April 18th) was devoted to a short presentation on ancient trade and some theoretical approaches to it, leading into a discussion of the infamous ‘gap’ in direct references to ‘trade’ in the Linear B records. Various topics, including evidence for loanwords and the use of ‘foreign’ ethnic adjectives were brought up a propos student reports read at the seminar.

My last session (April 25th) with the Linear B seminar included a presentation of Mycenaean warfare. We discussed some iconographic, archaeological (including osteoarchaeological) evidence for war and violence, before focusing on certain patterns in the texts which imply the military concerns of the Linear B administrations. We commented somewhat more extensively the Pylos ‘o-ka tablets’ and the records of chariot parts.

In all the above cases and with the constant help of Tom Palaima, many topics were covered so as to help students towards their final papers. The students themselves had a wide range of interests, including anthropology, field archaeology, Homer, Semitic studies and Indo-European languages. My participation in the Linear B seminar has been an unforgettable experience, which is even more valued since the opportunities to actually teach Linear B become fewer and fewer world-wide.

Over lunch, dinner and between other activities, I was especially pleased to be able to talk with colleagues about their current and future research. I discussed the social significance of drinking in early Greece with Adam Rabinowitz and various topics with Jamie Aprile, Stephen White and Nicolle Hirschfeld.

It was a particular pleasure to be able to talk extensively with Aren Wilson-Wright and Will Bibee on Semitic loanwords and possibilities (or probabilities) of ex Oriente transfer of ideology and practice into the Aegean.

Outside of PASP, I managed to ‘catch’ glimpses of really nice Austin weather (usually comfortably warm and only occasionally humid) and, especially, to attend some truly wonderful musical experiences, like hearing Jimmy LaFave at Threadgill’s south of the river and the LP’s playing at Ten Thousand Villages on SoCo.

These were always accompanied with exquisite Texan flavors. I will be sorry to miss some morning coffee rituals at Quack’s Cafe, which typically heralded the beginning of a productive day. Two visits to Polvos on South First Street helped me understand what a Tex-Mex taverna is like.

None of the above would have been conceivable without Tom Palaima’s amazing hospitality, which in a miraculous way made you only do things you already wanted to do. Tom created an ideal environment for me to work and this is a true luxury, and one that is becoming hard to find.

Although this may sound like one of those typical ‘acknowledgement’ comments, I do, however, feel obliged to note that his role in the promotion of Mycenaean studies is undeniably seminal, as it was evident to this visitor that the success of PASP has been achieved through the personal commitment and skill of its director. This reflects on the University’s academic reputation enormously and is more than anything else responsible for the excellent impression UT Austin made on me.

I also want to thank students and staff who helped make my stay so rewarding: Dygo Tosa and Kelly McClinton in PASP, Beth Chichester, who handled computer and audiovisual matters, Gina Giovanonne and Joe Sosa in the Classics Library, Maree Norfleet Williams in the Classics Department administrative offices, and the chair of the department Stephen White.

I do carry with me back in Greece the memory of a special experience and will always feel privileged to have been invited here.

Finally a special thank to Julie Strong and her husband Stuart who made my living in Austin so pleasant.


VP the LP’s 2nd greatest fan

VP sad day of departure superhero vision

VP on side of UT Tower

VP man who likes things BIG

VP in Shepler’s

VP alcove of UT Tower

Petrakis traveling bard in SoCo

March 10, 2009

Added several Palaima reviews:
Review of Ancient Rome and Modern America
Review of The Inheritance of Rome: A History of Europe from 400 to 1000
Review of The Dynamite Club: How a Bombing in Fin-de-Siècle Paris Ignited the Age of Modern Terror

Added several Palaima editorials:
“Woody Guthrie’s songs can help you focus on the spirit of the season”
“UTSA is throwing a Hail Mary pass”
“‘Happy New Year!'”
“(with Nathan Tublitz) Barack Obama and the International Education Bowl”
“(with Emily Schenk) Hold onto hope for justice”
“The price of corporate culture at UT”

April 24, 2009

Added several articles:

by Dimitri Nakassis
[PDF]”Named individuals and the Mycenaean state at Pylos,” Colloquium Romanum: Atti del XII colloquio internazionale di micenologia. Rome 2008, pp. 549-561.

by Stephie Nikoloudis
[PDF]”The role of the ra-wa-ke-ta. Insights from PY Un 718,” Colloquium Romanum: Atti del XII colloquio internazionale di micenologia. Rome 2008, pp. 587-594.

by Tom Palaima:
[PDF]”A new Linear B inscription from the land down under: AUS HO(ME) Bo 2008,” in F. Louise A. Hitchcock, Robert Laffineur and Janice Crowley eds., DAIS. The Aegean Feast (Aegaeum 29), Liège and Austin 2008, pp. 429-432.
[PDF]”The significance of Myceneaean words relating to meals, meal rituals, and food,” in Louise A. Hitchcock, Robert Laffineur and Janice Crowley eds., DAIS. The Aegean Feast (Aegaeum 29), Liège and Austin 2008, pp. 383-389.

September 29, 2009

Upcoming Event:
As part of the Odyssey program at UT, the Classics department will be presenting a lecture series entitled, Classical Worlds: Rediscovering Ancient Greece and Romefrom September 28-November 9, 6:00-7:30 p.m.

As part of this series, on September 28th, Tom Palaima will be presenting on “THE FIRST EUROPEAN INFO TECH REVOLUTION: LINEAR B, BOOM AND BUST IN THE BRONZE AGE KINGDOM OF PYLOS.” Check out the brochure for more details.

Added Palaima articles:

Added Palaimaeditorials: